Holiday Stuffed Shells Recipe - Pasta w/ Potatoes, Stuffing, Gravy (2024)

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy.

Leftovers just got a makeover with these Holiday Stuffed Shells! Leftover potatoes, stuffing, and turkey get smothered in a red wine mushroom gravy and stuffed into pasta shells!

Today’s recipe is sponsored by our friends at Barefoot Wine & Bubbly. The holidays just wouldn’t be complete without them!

You guyyyyyyyys. T-minus TWO days until Turkey Day. Who else is excited?

I’m already day dreaming about all of the stuffing, mashed potatoes, corn casserole, rolls, cookies, pie, and . . .

the leftovers.

Usually, I’m not really a fan of leftovers, but today, I’ve kicked Thanksgiving leftovers up a notch and turned them into Holiday Stuffed Shells.

Say whaaaat?

Basically, these are jumbo pasta shells stuffed with all your favorite Thanksgiving foods – mashed potatoes, stuffing, and turkey – and my secret ingredient: red wine mushroom gravy.

Yeahhhh.

Leftovers have never looked quite so good.

Personally, I get bored with eating the same thing day after day (but hate wasting food), so I’m often forced to get creative with my leftovers.

Here’s the thing though.

It’s still gotta be easy, becausethe whole point in eating leftovers is you’ve already done the work. All you have to do now, is cookyour already made foodin the microwave for a quick secondand you’ve got yourself an easy, delicious, homemade meal that you actually made threedays ago. 😉

BUT. Like I said. I get bored.

So what do I do?

Create quick and easy recipes using leftovers.

You could do the basic leftover turkey/ham sandwich, but I wanted to take things even further.

Enter: Holiday Stuffed Shells.

All you really need to do is boil some pasta – e.a.s.y. – and whip up a quick red wine mushroom gravy – easier than it sounds, promise – and assemble!

Ready?

While your pasta shells are cooking, melt some butter in a saute pan. Once hot, throw in some sliced mushrooms and black pepper. Then sprinkle on some flour (this helps the gravy thicken) and stir in chicken broth and Barefoot Cabernet Sauvignon.

You only use a 1/2 cup of the wine, so I highly recommend that while the sauce thickens you pour yourself a glass (this is my FAVE red wine, so I may have poured myself two 😉 ).

Once the gravy has thickened, you’ll stir in a touch more butter and some half-and-half – because why not, season it with a little salt and you’re done! Easy peasy, right?

It’s totally simple, but so perfect, because mushrooms and wine are a match made in h.e.a.v.e.n.

Now. To assemble theHoliday Stuffed Shells:

Shell –> gravy –> potatoes –> turkey –> stuffing –> baking pan –> bake –> eat.

The taste and texture will vary based on your holiday leftovers, but for us, we used our crockpot mashed potatoes and best ever sausage stuffing, so these Holiday Stuffed Shells were exploding with texture and flavor.

I love biting into the shells and getting a little crunch from the stuffing (ours has apples in it), the creaminess from the potatoes, and themeaty, rich texture from the gravy.

Honestly, forget Thanksgiving dinner, I’m ready for leftovers!

Cheers!

– Jennifer

Thanks again to Barefoot Wine & Bubbly for sponsoring today’s post!